Adolf Hitler’s notorious propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels committed suicide along with his wife in 1945. Before committing suicide, he also killed his children. Although Joseph Goebbels was destroyed along with his entire family eighty years ago, his notorious propaganda policy—“If a lie is repeated again and again, it begins to appear true”—is still being used as a political ploy in different countries even today. Bangladesh is no exception to this. In the politics of this country, it is not at all uncommon to promote a lie loudly and collectively and turn it into an ‘almost-truth.’ As a political party in Bangladesh, the biggest victim of this Goebbelsian political ploy is probably the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP). This most popular political party among the general people of Bangladesh has comparatively less support from the traditional media and social media. Taking advantage of this situation, the opponents of the BNP, with the help of various traditional media and social media, have made various false allegations against the party and turned them into ‘almost-truths.’ We may call these ‘Goebbelsian negative myths.’ Very recently, Honorable Member of Parliament Rumin Farhana became vocal in criticizing the BNP government by using one such Goebbelsian negative myth.
Honorable Member of Parliament Rumin Farhana said in her speech, “The BNP will come to power and Bangladesh will not become a champion in corruption—that cannot happen.” The basis of her statement is this myth propagated in a Goebbelsian manner by the Awami League and its allied intellectuals and media during the previous fascist regime: ‘Bangladesh became champion in corruption in the Transparency International report because of the corruption of the BNP-led coalition government (the Four-Party Alliance) during the 2001–06 term, and because of the corruption of this government, Bangladesh remained in the same position for five consecutive times.’ With the help of a section of intellectuals and the media, the then fascist government continued to propagate this misinformation in such a manner that many people became confused and eventually came to believe it. But when we investigate the truth and analyze the events, we find that the facts are not merely different; they are, in fact, completely opposite!
If we investigate the facts, we will see, by visiting the Transparency International website (https://www.transparency.org/en/), that Bangladesh was included in its Global Corruption Report for the first time in 2001, and it was in this year that Bangladesh became champion in corruption. Transparency International published this report on October 15, 2001. The report clearly states, “The Global Corruption Report 2001 was published in October 2001 and provides an overview of the state of corruption around the globe, covering the period from July 2000 to June 2001.” That is, this report was prepared on the basis of data from the period between July 2000 and June 2001, the entire period of which the Awami League government led by Sheikh Hasina was in state power in Bangladesh. It is worth mentioning here that although the 2001 Global Corruption Report was published on October 15 of that year, its background paper was published in June of the same year. This background paper stated, “Indeed, another country enters in the index this year and obtains a worse position than Nigeria: Bangladesh. In case we had sufficient data on Bangladesh already in the past, this country might have obtained the worst position already then.” Therefore, it would not be unreasonable to believe that in the previous few years as well (when the Awami League was in state power), the corruption situation in Bangladesh was similarly at a champion level.
In this context, it should be mentioned that many of those who are now forty-five or above may remember that when the background paper of the Global Corruption Report was published in June 2001, the ministers of the then Awami League government started shouting that Transparency International had prepared the report after taking money from the BNP. Since this information was published only a few months before the election (national parliamentary election – 2001), the Awami League found itself in a very embarrassing situation, and for this reason, Awami supporters reacted strongly. But the interesting thing is that three or four years after its defeat in the 2001 election, the Awami League started saying in unison, in a Goebbelsian manner, that Bangladesh had become champion in corruption during the BNP period. By repeating this over and over, they almost established this misinformation and almost made the correct information—that Bangladesh had become champion in corruption for the first time during the Awami League period—disappear.
Anyway, if we analyze a little further the information available on the Transparency International website, we can see that according to the standard of Transparency International, a corruption-free or clean score is 10. When Bangladesh became champion in corruption for the first time in 2001 during the Awami League period, Bangladesh’s clean score was only 0.4. On October 10, 2001, the government of the then BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia was formed. One of her successes in preventing corruption was that within only eight months of forming the government, in July 2002, her government succeeded in raising the clean score to 1.2, which was three times better than the previous year’s position. Not only that, but it was also during her tenure that Bangladesh began to show consistent success in achieving a higher clean score. In 2003, Bangladesh’s clean score was 1.3; in 2004, 1.4; in 2005, 1.7; and in 2006, Bangladesh’s clean score reached 2. In 2006, during Begum Khaleda Zia’s government, Bangladesh was freed for the first time from the stigma of being champion in corruption. In that year, Haiti became champion in corruption. Bangladesh left behind not only Haiti but also Myanmar, Iraq, and Guyana. Thus, it appears that it was Begum Khaleda Zia’s government that freed Bangladesh from the stigma of being champion in corruption. It did take several years to achieve this. However, if we look closely, we can see that Begum Zia’s government succeeded in improving the 0.4 score inherited from the previous Awami League government by five times and raising it to 2. This positive leap unquestionably deserves to be considered a major capability and success of Begum Khaleda Zia’s government at that time.
Therefore, if we analyze the information available on the Transparency International website, it is proved that the negative credit for making Bangladesh champion in corruption does not belong to the BNP government but to the then Awami League government. The Awami League government of that time had brought Bangladesh’s clean score down to such a low level that it took the subsequent BNP government five years to rise from that position and free the country from that stigma. Therefore, the statement that ‘Bangladesh became champion in corruption in the Transparency International report because of the corruption of the BNP-led coalition government (the Four-Party Alliance), and because of the corruption of this government, Bangladesh remained in the same position for five consecutive times’ is nothing but a falsehood-based utterance that conceals the actual truth. Therefore, this negative myth is also completely Goebbelsian and unacceptable.
But Honorable Member of Parliament Rumin Farhana is a wise personality. It is difficult to believe that she has been misled by such falsehood. Many believe that the Honorable Member of Parliament has resorted to this Goebbelsian political ploy of falsehood because of her personal resentment toward the BNP. This assumption may be correct, or it may not be. However, it is true that in Bangladesh’s politics, the BNP is the biggest victim of Goebbelsian political ploys. Now the BNP itself has to find out why the party so easily becomes a victim of various false propaganda. At first sight, it appears that the lack of political study among the party’s leaders and activists, the limited presence and low level of activity of the party’s leaders and activists on social media, and the lack of the desired cooperation from the traditional media have turned the BNP into an easy victim of Goebbelsian political ploys. The sooner the BNP leadership realizes this organizational weakness and finds a way to overcome it, the better it will be for both the party and Bangladesh. Therefore, the BNP must do this quickly, because, as the ruling party, the development and welfare of the state are now intertwined with the BNP’s well-being and efficiency.
(Professor Dr. Mostofa Nazmul Mansur
Department of Philosophy
Jahangirnagar University)
